The Strange Case of the Grace I’s Detention

By François Nicoullaud

On July 4, the government of Gibraltar detained in its waters a Panamanian ship, the Grace I, allegedly on its way to deliver Iranian oil to a Syrian harbor. Immediately after the move, Gibraltar outlined in an official statement that the “action arose from information giving […] reasonable grounds to believe that the vessel, the Grace I, was acting in breach of European Union sanctions against Syria.” And it added: “We have reason to believe that the Grace I was carrying its shipment of crude oil to the Banyas Refinery in Syria.” One day later, the Gibraltar Supreme Court issued an order confirming that the detention of the Grace I for another 14 days was required “for the purposes of compliance with the EU Regulation 36/2012 on sanctions on Syria.”

On what grounds could a European government detain a non-European vessel transporting to Syria crude oil extracted by a non-European country, Iran?

The European Union firmly condemns the principle of secondary, or extra-territorial sanctions, widely practiced by the United States. Therefore, European prohibitions address primarily European nationals as well as persons and entities active on European territory. European law cannot prohibit a Panamanian ship from carrying what it wishes in open seas (except, of course, products targeted by international law, like drugs or undeclared nuclear materials). However, it can forbid European insurance companies from insuring a ship or its freight, it can forbid European banks from financing the venture, it can detain the ship if it stops in a European harbor, it can forbid the freight from being brought ashore. But for this, the ship itself, its freight, or its destination must be subject to European sanctions.

Obviously, the Grace I, as a ship, was not liable to European sanctions as long as it did not enter European territorial waters: Spain’s or Gibraltar’s. Looking at the delimitation of territorial waters in the Strait of Gibraltar, it is difficult to believe that the Grace I penetrated Gibraltar’s very modest territorial waters, save for a technical stop. But, according to a further official statement from the Gibraltar Government, this is precisely what happened. Obviously, this was an ill-advised move.

What about the oil it was carrying? Following the implementation of the Vienna nuclear agreement, all European sanctions concerning Iranian oil have been lifted.

Now about the destination? Syria is clearly under European sanctions, but that does not mean that all activities and persons in Syria are subject to a European blockade. A blockade, in international law, is an act of war.

EU Regulation 36/2012, quoted by the Gibraltar Supreme Court as the legal ground for the detention, prohibits the delivery to Syria of equipment and technology that might be used for internal repression, dual-use items (nuclear material and equipment), and equipment, technology, and software of interest for military use. Four articles refer one way or another to oil. Article 6 prohibits the import, purchase, or transport of oil originating in Syria. Article 7 prohibits the sale and export of jet fuel to Syria. Articles 8 and 9 prohibit the shipment of equipment, technology, and assistance to the Syrian oil industry. There is nothing is this regulation that specifically prohibits the delivery of oil to Syria. But Chapter V—“Freezing of Funds and Economic Resources”—and its article 14 state that “no funds and economic resources” shall be made available to persons and entities listed in an Annex II. Annex II lists several oil companies and refineries, including the Baniyas Refinery Company, which the government of Gibraltar has presented as the alleged destination of the Grace I’s cargo. This could be the legal ground for the detention of the ship, if indeed the sale of oil to a refinery is a way “to make available an economic resource” to it.

Iran, for its part, has denied that the Grace I was in Gibraltar’s territorial waters when the UK Marines boarded it and also denied that the ship was heading to Syria. It has formally protested this “act of piracy.” Interestingly, the Spanish Minister of Foreign Affairs hinted that the ship’s detention was provoked by a tip and a request coming from the United States.

Aside from some Iranian threats of reprisals, the case up to now has been dealt with at the legal and diplomatic levels. As long as these ways are not exhausted—and even after—Iran has no real interest in carrying out its threats to reciprocate by seizing a British tanker in the Persian Gulf. With such a move, Tehran would antagonize the European countries that, for the time being, have stayed aloof from the quarrel and certainly other countries as well.

What could be an acceptable way out for the two parties? First, let’s keep in mind that the Gibraltar jurisdictions, in order to confirm the seizure the Grace I’s cargo, need documented, unquestionable evidence of its Syrian destination. Lacking such evidence, they would have no other choice than to release the ship. The crew—which apparently includes no Iranians—is presently being questioned. Given that the oil cargo in question has not reached its alleged destination, the judges could also consider that the offense has not yet been established.

All in all, there are serious grounds for releasing the Grace I, perhaps with a court injunction not to come close to Syrian shores. In that case, the ship would better avoid further risks and return to its homeport. To put an end to this strange episode, that would be a lesser evil.

François Nicoullaud’s diplomatic career (1964 to 2005) brought him to New York, Chile, Berlin, Bombay, and finally to Budapest and Tehran as French ambassador. In the French Foreign Ministry he was in charge of cultural development as well as non-proliferation issues. He has also served in the Ministry of Interior as a diplomatic advisor and in the Ministry of Defense as First Assistant to the Minister. Since 2005, he has been active as a political analyst in international affairs, concentrating on Iran and the Middle East. He has also authored a book based on his experience entitled, “The Turban and the Rose” (Ramsey, Paris, 2006).

This article was originally published by “Lobe Log



Over 100 fighters killed in clashes in northwest Syria since Wednesday

ISIS bombing outside Syrian church wounds 11; 13 others killed by car bombing in Afrin

Britain is a direct partner in aggression on Syria

Iraq:’ Four militia members killed as Iraq launches anti-ISIS operation in Diyala

Majorities of U.S. veterans, public say the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were not worth fighting

Iran Guards say strike ‘terrorists’ in Iraqi Kurdistan

Iran unleashes fire on terrorist positions along border with Iraqi Kurdistan

Trump’s Iran policy has killed far beyond 150 Iranians: Fareed ZakariaPresident Donald Trump’s “incoherent and ill-planned” Iran policy openly targets civilians and is breeding regional resentment against the US, Time magazine and CNN’s Fareed Zakaria says.

Chronically ill Iranians struggle to access medicine under US sanctions

House passes bipartisan amendment barring Trump from striking Iran without congressional approval

Iran’s Revolutionary Guards deny trying to stop UK tanker in Persian Gulf

UK to send second warship to the Gulf

UK urged to immediately release Iranian supertanker, avoid ‘dangerous’ game

United Arab Emirates pulls out of Saudi-led coalition in Yemen

UN drafts ‘list of shame’ over child deaths in Yemen

The House Rebukes Trump on Yemen Again: Lawmakers voted 236 to 193 to prohibit the administration from using funds to support the Saudi-led military operations — either with munitions or with intelligence

REVEALED: The Saudi death squad MBS uses to silence dissent

Turkey defies US as Russian S-400 missile defence arrives

Entry ban at Israeli city park provokes apartheid warningsHuman rights groups have warned that the ban marks a growing trend by local authorities representing the Jewish majority towards explicit separation of public space in ways reminiscent of apartheid South Africa.

The Jeffrey Epstein scandal has found its way into Israel’s elections


Several killed in bomb, gun attack on Somalia hotel: officials

Four killed as car bomb targets funeral in Libya’s Benghazi

Leading Daesh member reportedly killed in Libya

UK spy agencies used details extracted under torture to detain Libyans, say lawyers

New Coup Attempt in Sudan Fails

South Africa; Army to be deployed to quell violent crime in Cape Town


Afghanistan: Child suicide bomber kills five, injures 40 in wedding attack

Afghan commandos killed four at medical clinic: human rights group

India: 2.5 Million Litres of Water Arrives by train in Parched Chennai

U.S. officials push for sanctions on China over oil purchases from Iran

China: US ‘playing with fire’ over Taiwan arms sale

China to impose sanctions on U.S. firms over weapon sales to Taiwan

The World Acquires More Gold While China Is Dumping U.S. TreasuriesCurrently China holds well north of $1 TRILLION in U.S. Treasuries – debt – that you and I, the tax payers of this country, send to interest payments month after month to China for them to continue holding our debt.

Beijing Signals Talks at Early Stage as Trump Vents FrustrationSigns are growing that President Donald Trump won’t get what he wants anytime soon.

Watch: Beijing signals that it’s preparing to play hard ball as Friday tariff hike approaches

Xinjiang and Uyghurs — What You’re Not Being Told: What’s the real story? Let’s go beyond exaggeration, distortion and sensationalism.

India lifted 271 mn people out of poverty between 2006 and 2016: UN

U.N. to probe Philippines drug war deaths: Philippine activists say tens of thousands are being killed as police terrorise poor communities


Woman killed, shops looted in France after Algeria’s football win

Ukraine to Chemically Castrate Pedophiles

‘Any lie will do’: Watch head of US intl broadcast agency LIE to Congress about RT’s funding

France passes tax on tech giants despite US threats

Jeremy Corbyn is Attacked Because He is Anti-Capitalist, not Anti-Semitic

Jonathan Cook: With Panorama’s hatchet job on Labour antisemitism, BBC has become pro-Tory media

The Guardian publishes, then censors Jewish open letter defending smeared pro-Corbyn Labour MP Chris Williamson


Lock them up! FTC votes to approve $5 billion settlement with Facebook in privacy probe

Amazon Alexa calls the police as man allegedly assaults his girlfriend

Japanese spacecraft has landed on an asteroid after blasting it with a bullet. The mission will bring back rock samples to Earth.

Invoking WikiLeaks And Torture Report, CIA Pushes For Expansion Of Secrecy Law To Stifle Public Criticism

The 10 Countries Most Vulnerable to Climate Change Will Experience Population Booms in the Coming Decades

Climate change: How hot cities could be in 2050

Bombshell Claim: Scientists Find “Man-made Climate Change Doesn’t Exist In Practice”


Jobs Decrease in Honduras: The rate of underemployment shot up in 2018 to 62.8 percent in Honduras, higher than the 56 percent registered in 2017.

Ousted Honduran President Zelaya: The 2009 U.S.-Backed Coup Helped Cause Today’s Migrant Crisis

How US policy in Honduras set the stage for today’s migration

Morales welcomes Russia to Latin America to counter Washington’s hegemony

U.S. Military Plans to Battle Russia, China and Iran’s ‘Most Disturbing’ Influence in Venezuela: The head of the Pentagon’s Southern Command warned that Russia, China and Iran were expanding their influence in Latin America, particularly in Venezuela, where they support a government the United States seeks to depose.

In pictures: ‘Help, 40 Days Here!’, Migrants in US Border Facilities:

ICE to Launch Nationwide Raids to Arrest Undocumented Migrants

Elizabeth Warren Unveils Immigration Plan That Would Decriminalize Border Crossings

Ocasio-Cortez wants to ax Homeland Security; some conservatives didn’t want it

U.S. House of Representatives Creates Requirement That There Be Some Basis for Any Foreign Bases: Representatives passed an amendment requiring that the U.S. military provide Congress with the cost and the supposed national security benefits of every foreign military base or foreign military operation.

Ex-education secretary, 5 others held in Puerto Rico probe

‘This wasn’t just a briefing’: Pompeo grilled CIA analysts on Russia findings: He ultimately found no evidence of any wrongdoing, or that the analysts had been under political pressure to produce their findings.

Watch: Russiagate Falls Apart Even More Every Day (with Aaron Maté)

‘US$ is the only real currency!’ Trump demands banking regulation of bitcoin, Facebook’s Libra

Paul Craig Roberts: USD’s Reserve Currency Role at Risk as Nations Turn to Domestic Currencies, Gold

Watch: Another Ethically Challenged NYTimes “Journo” Is Covering Bernie

Trump Labor Secretary Acosta Resigns Amid Epstein Plea Deal Fallout

Jeffrey Epstein paid $350K to potential witnesses in sex trafficking case, prosecutors say

Welcome to the Hellfire Club: Our elites cavorted with a pedophile, almost certainly aware of what he was up to. This is how revolutions begin.

Ann Coulter Thinks Epstein Had a “State Sponsor” & Was Running a “Blackmailing” Operation

Stories you won’t hear about Epstein in the MSM

Drugmaker Pays Largest Opioid Settlement In History To Make Investigations Go Away

Sell your soul? U.S. Army offering $40,000 bonus for people to join the infantry